## Issue Addressed
NA
## Proposed Changes
Rather than spawning new tasks on the tokio executor to process each HTTP API request, send the tasks to the `BeaconProcessor`. This achieves:
1. Places a bound on how many concurrent requests are being served (i.e., how many we are actually trying to compute at one time).
1. Places a bound on how many requests can be awaiting a response at one time (i.e., starts dropping requests when we have too many queued).
1. Allows the BN prioritise HTTP requests with respect to messages coming from the P2P network (i.e., proiritise importing gossip blocks rather than serving API requests).
Presently there are two levels of priorities:
- `Priority::P0`
- The beacon processor will prioritise these above everything other than importing new blocks.
- Roughly all validator-sensitive endpoints.
- `Priority::P1`
- The beacon processor will prioritise practically all other P2P messages over these, except for historical backfill things.
- Everything that's not `Priority::P0`
The `--http-enable-beacon-processor false` flag can be supplied to revert back to the old behaviour of spawning new `tokio` tasks for each request:
```
--http-enable-beacon-processor <BOOLEAN>
The beacon processor is a scheduler which provides quality-of-service and DoS protection. When set to
"true", HTTP API requests will queued and scheduled alongside other tasks. When set to "false", HTTP API
responses will be executed immediately. [default: true]
```
## New CLI Flags
I added some other new CLI flags:
```
--beacon-processor-aggregate-batch-size <INTEGER>
Specifies the number of gossip aggregate attestations in a signature verification batch. Higher values may
reduce CPU usage in a healthy network while lower values may increase CPU usage in an unhealthy or hostile
network. [default: 64]
--beacon-processor-attestation-batch-size <INTEGER>
Specifies the number of gossip attestations in a signature verification batch. Higher values may reduce CPU
usage in a healthy network whilst lower values may increase CPU usage in an unhealthy or hostile network.
[default: 64]
--beacon-processor-max-workers <INTEGER>
Specifies the maximum concurrent tasks for the task scheduler. Increasing this value may increase resource
consumption. Reducing the value may result in decreased resource usage and diminished performance. The
default value is the number of logical CPU cores on the host.
--beacon-processor-reprocess-queue-len <INTEGER>
Specifies the length of the queue for messages requiring delayed processing. Higher values may prevent
messages from being dropped while lower values may help protect the node from becoming overwhelmed.
[default: 12288]
```
I needed to add the max-workers flag since the "simulator" flavor tests started failing with HTTP timeouts on the test assertions. I believe they were failing because the Github runners only have 2 cores and there just weren't enough workers available to process our requests in time. I added the other flags since they seem fun to fiddle with.
## Additional Info
I bumped the timeouts on the "simulator" flavor test from 4s to 8s. The prioritisation of consensus messages seems to be causing slower responses, I guess this is what we signed up for 🤷
The `validator/register` validator has some special handling because the relays have a bad habit of timing out on these calls. It seems like a waste of a `BeaconProcessor` worker to just wait for the builder API HTTP response, so we spawn a new `tokio` task to wait for a builder response.
I've added an optimisation for the `GET beacon/states/{state_id}/validators/{validator_id}` endpoint in [efbabe3](efbabe3252). That's the endpoint the VC uses to resolve pubkeys to validator indices, and it's the endpoint that was causing us grief. Perhaps I should move that into a new PR, not sure.
*Replaces #4434. It is identical, but this PR has a smaller diff due to a curated commit history.*
## Issue Addressed
NA
## Proposed Changes
This PR moves the scheduling logic for the `BeaconProcessor` into a new crate in `beacon_node/beacon_processor`. Previously it existed in the `beacon_node/network` crate.
This addresses a circular-dependency problem where it's not possible to use the `BeaconProcessor` from the `beacon_chain` crate. The `network` crate depends on the `beacon_chain` crate (`network -> beacon_chain`), but importing the `BeaconProcessor` into the `beacon_chain` crate would create a circular dependancy of `beacon_chain -> network`.
The `BeaconProcessor` was designed to provide queuing and prioritized scheduling for messages from the network. It has proven to be quite valuable and I believe we'd make Lighthouse more stable and effective by using it elsewhere. In particular, I think we should use the `BeaconProcessor` for:
1. HTTP API requests.
1. Scheduled tasks in the `BeaconChain` (e.g., state advance).
Using the `BeaconProcessor` for these tasks would help prevent the BN from becoming overwhelmed and would also help it to prioritize operations (e.g., choosing to process blocks from gossip before responding to low-priority HTTP API requests).
## Additional Info
This PR is intended to have zero impact on runtime behaviour. It aims to simply separate the *scheduling* code (i.e., the `BeaconProcessor`) from the *business logic* in the `network` crate (i.e., the `Worker` impls). Future PRs (see #4462) can build upon these works to actually use the `BeaconProcessor` for more operations.
I've gone to some effort to use `git mv` to make the diff look more like "file was moved and modified" rather than "file was deleted and a new one added". This should reduce review burden and help maintain commit attribution.
## Issue Addressed
Add support for ipv6 and dual stack in lighthouse.
## Proposed Changes
From an user perspective, now setting an ipv6 address, optionally configuring the ports should feel exactly the same as using an ipv4 address. If listening over both ipv4 and ipv6 then the user needs to:
- use the `--listen-address` two times (ipv4 and ipv6 addresses)
- `--port6` becomes then required
- `--discovery-port6` can now be used to additionally configure the ipv6 udp port
### Rough list of code changes
- Discovery:
- Table filter and ip mode set to match the listening config.
- Ipv6 address, tcp port and udp port set in the ENR builder
- Reported addresses now check which tcp port to give to libp2p
- LH Network Service:
- Can listen over Ipv6, Ipv4, or both. This uses two sockets. Using mapped addresses is disabled from libp2p and it's the most compatible option.
- NetworkGlobals:
- No longer stores udp port since was not used at all. Instead, stores the Ipv4 and Ipv6 TCP ports.
- NetworkConfig:
- Update names to make it clear that previous udp and tcp ports in ENR were Ipv4
- Add fields to configure Ipv6 udp and tcp ports in the ENR
- Include advertised enr Ipv6 address.
- Add type to model Listening address that's either Ipv4, Ipv6 or both. A listening address includes the ip, udp port and tcp port.
- UPnP:
- Kept only for ipv4
- Cli flags:
- `--listen-addresses` now can take up to two values
- `--port` will apply to ipv4 or ipv6 if only one listening address is given. If two listening addresses are given it will apply only to Ipv4.
- `--port6` New flag required when listening over ipv4 and ipv6 that applies exclusively to Ipv6.
- `--discovery-port` will now apply to ipv4 and ipv6 if only one listening address is given.
- `--discovery-port6` New flag to configure the individual udp port of ipv6 if listening over both ipv4 and ipv6.
- `--enr-udp-port` Updated docs to specify that it only applies to ipv4. This is an old behaviour.
- `--enr-udp6-port` Added to configure the enr udp6 field.
- `--enr-tcp-port` Updated docs to specify that it only applies to ipv4. This is an old behaviour.
- `--enr-tcp6-port` Added to configure the enr tcp6 field.
- `--enr-addresses` now can take two values.
- `--enr-match` updated behaviour.
- Common:
- rename `unused_port` functions to specify that they are over ipv4.
- add functions to get unused ports over ipv6.
- Testing binaries
- Updated code to reflect network config changes and unused_port changes.
## Additional Info
TODOs:
- use two sockets in discovery. I'll get back to this and it's on https://github.com/sigp/discv5/pull/160
- lcli allow listening over two sockets in generate_bootnodes_enr
- add at least one smoke flag for ipv6 (I have tested this and works for me)
- update the book
## Issue Addressed
#3006
## Proposed Changes
This PR changes the default behaviour of lighthouse to ignore discovered IPs that are not globally routable. It adds a CLI flag, --enable-local-discovery to permit the non-global IPs in discovery.
NOTE: We should take care in merging this as I will break current set-ups that rely on local IP discovery. I made this the non-default behaviour because we dont really want to be wasting resources attempting to connect to non-routable addresses and we dont want to propagate these to others (on the chance we can connect to one of these local nodes), improving discoveries efficiency.
## Description
The `eth2_libp2p` crate was originally named and designed to incorporate a simple libp2p integration into lighthouse. Since its origins the crates purpose has expanded dramatically. It now houses a lot more sophistication that is specific to lighthouse and no longer just a libp2p integration.
As of this writing it currently houses the following high-level lighthouse-specific logic:
- Lighthouse's implementation of the eth2 RPC protocol and specific encodings/decodings
- Integration and handling of ENRs with respect to libp2p and eth2
- Lighthouse's discovery logic, its integration with discv5 and logic about searching and handling peers.
- Lighthouse's peer manager - This is a large module handling various aspects of Lighthouse's network, such as peer scoring, handling pings and metadata, connection maintenance and recording, etc.
- Lighthouse's peer database - This is a collection of information stored for each individual peer which is specific to lighthouse. We store connection state, sync state, last seen ips and scores etc. The data stored for each peer is designed for various elements of the lighthouse code base such as syncing and the http api.
- Gossipsub scoring - This stores a collection of gossipsub 1.1 scoring mechanisms that are continuously analyssed and updated based on the ethereum 2 networks and how Lighthouse performs on these networks.
- Lighthouse specific types for managing gossipsub topics, sync status and ENR fields
- Lighthouse's network HTTP API metrics - A collection of metrics for lighthouse network monitoring
- Lighthouse's custom configuration of all networking protocols, RPC, gossipsub, discovery, identify and libp2p.
Therefore it makes sense to rename the crate to be more akin to its current purposes, simply that it manages the majority of Lighthouse's network stack. This PR renames this crate to `lighthouse_network`
Co-authored-by: Paul Hauner <paul@paulhauner.com>
## Issue Addressed
NA
## Proposed Changes
This PR is near-identical to https://github.com/sigp/lighthouse/pull/2652, however it is to be merged into `unstable` instead of `merge-f2f`. Please see that PR for reasoning.
I'm making this duplicate PR to merge to `unstable` in an effort to shrink the diff between `unstable` and `merge-f2f` by doing smaller, lead-up PRs.
## Additional Info
NA
## Proposed Changes
* Implement the validator client and HTTP API changes necessary to support Altair
Co-authored-by: realbigsean <seananderson33@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Michael Sproul <michael@sigmaprime.io>
## Proposed Changes
Implement the consensus changes necessary for the upcoming Altair hard fork.
## Additional Info
This is quite a heavy refactor, with pivotal types like the `BeaconState` and `BeaconBlock` changing from structs to enums. This ripples through the whole codebase with field accesses changing to methods, e.g. `state.slot` => `state.slot()`.
Co-authored-by: realbigsean <seananderson33@gmail.com>
## Issue Addressed
`test_dht_persistence` failing
## Proposed Changes
Bind `NetworkService::start` to an underscore prefixed variable rather than `_`. `_` was causing it to be dropped immediately
This was failing 5/100 times before this update, but I haven't been able to get it to fail after updating it
Co-authored-by: realbigsean <seananderson33@gmail.com>
## Issue Addressed
#2046
## Proposed Changes
The log was originally intended to verify the correct logic and ordering of events when scoring peers. The queued tasks can be structured in such a way that peers can be banned after they are disconnected. Therefore the error log is now downgraded to debug log.
## Issue Addressed
Closes#2042
## Proposed Changes
Pass blocks that fail gossip verification to the slasher. Blocks that are successfully verified are not passed immediately, but will be passed as part of full block verification.
## Description
This PR updates Lighthouse to tokio 0.3. It includes a number of dependency updates and some structural changes as to how we create and spawn tasks.
This also brings with it a number of various improvements:
- Discv5 update
- Libp2p update
- Fix for recompilation issues
- Improved UPnP port mapping handling
- Futures dependency update
- Log downgrade to traces for rejecting peers when we've reached our max
Co-authored-by: blacktemplar <blacktemplar@a1.net>
* Initial rebase
* Remove old code
* Correct release tests
* Rebase commit
* Remove eth2-testnet dep on eth2libp2p
* Remove crates lost in rebase
* Remove unused dep
The PR:
* Adds the ability to generate a crucial test scenario that isn't possible with `BeaconChainHarness` (i.e. two blocks occupying the same slot; previously forks necessitated skipping slots):
* New testing API: Instead of repeatedly calling add_block(), you generate a sorted `Vec<Slot>` and leave it up to the framework to generate blocks at those slots.
* Jumping backwards to an earlier epoch is a hard error, so that tests necessarily generate blocks in a epoch-by-epoch manner.
* Configures the test logger so that output is printed on the console in case a test fails. The logger also plays well with `--nocapture`, contrary to the existing testing framework
* Rewrites existing fork pruning tests to use the new API
* Adds a tests that triggers finalization at a non epoch boundary slot
* Renamed `BeaconChainYoke` to `BeaconChainTestingRig` because the former has been too confusing
* Fixed multiple tests (e.g. `block_production_different_shuffling_long`, `delete_blocks_and_states`, `shuffling_compatible_simple_fork`) that relied on a weird (and accidental) feature of the old `BeaconChainHarness` that attestations aren't produced for epochs earlier than the current one, thus masking potential bugs in test cases.
Co-authored-by: Michael Sproul <michael@sigmaprime.io>
## Issue Addressed
#1494
## Proposed Changes
- Give the TaskExecutor the sender side of a channel that a task can clone to request shutting down
- The receiver side of this channel is in environment and now we block until ctrl+c or an internal shutdown signal is received
- The swarm now informs when it has reached 0 listeners
- The network receives this message and requests the shutdown
## Issue Addressed
#1384
Only catch, as currently implemented, when dialing the multiaddr nodes, there is no way to ask the peer manager if they are already connected or dialing
* Layer do_atomically() abstractions properly
* Reduce allocs and DRY get_key_for_col()
* Parameterize HotColdDB with hot and cold item stores
* -impl Store for MemoryStore
* Replace Store uses with HotColdDB
* Ditch Store trait
* cargo fmt
* Style fix
* Readd missing dep that broke the build
* Add logging on shutdown
* Replace tokio::spawn with handle.spawn
* Upgrade tokio
* Add a task executor
* Beacon chain tasks use task executor
* Validator client tasks use task executor
* Rename runtime_handle to executor
* Add duration histograms; minor fixes
* Cleanup
* Fix logs
* Fix tests
* Remove random file
* Get enr dependency instead of libp2p
* Address some review comments
* Libp2p takes a TaskExecutor
* Ugly fix libp2p tests
* Move TaskExecutor to own file
* Upgrade Dockerfile rust version
* Minor fixes
* Revert "Ugly fix libp2p tests"
This reverts commit 58d4bb690f52de28d893943b7504d2d0c6621429.
* Pretty fix libp2p tests
* Add spawn_without_exit; change Counter to Gauge
* Tidy
* Move log from RuntimeContext to TaskExecutor
* Fix errors
* Replace histogram with int_gauge for async tasks
* Fix todo
* Fix memory leak in test by exiting all spawned tasks at the end
* Port eth1 lib to use stable futures
* Port eth1_test_rig to stable futures
* Port eth1 tests to stable futures
* Port genesis service to stable futures
* Port genesis tests to stable futures
* Port beacon_chain to stable futures
* Port lcli to stable futures
* Fix eth1_test_rig (#1014)
* Fix lcli
* Port timer to stable futures
* Fix timer
* Port websocket_server to stable futures
* Port notifier to stable futures
* Add TODOS
* Update hashmap hashset to stable futures
* Adds panic test to hashset delay
* Port remote_beacon_node to stable futures
* Fix lcli merge conflicts
* Non rpc stuff compiles
* protocol.rs compiles
* Port websockets, timer and notifier to stable futures (#1035)
* Fix lcli
* Port timer to stable futures
* Fix timer
* Port websocket_server to stable futures
* Port notifier to stable futures
* Add TODOS
* Port remote_beacon_node to stable futures
* Partial eth2-libp2p stable future upgrade
* Finished first round of fighting RPC types
* Further progress towards porting eth2-libp2p adds caching to discovery
* Update behaviour
* RPC handler to stable futures
* Update RPC to master libp2p
* Network service additions
* Fix the fallback transport construction (#1102)
* Correct warning
* Remove hashmap delay
* Compiling version of eth2-libp2p
* Update all crates versions
* Fix conversion function and add tests (#1113)
* Port validator_client to stable futures (#1114)
* Add PH & MS slot clock changes
* Account for genesis time
* Add progress on duties refactor
* Add simple is_aggregator bool to val subscription
* Start work on attestation_verification.rs
* Add progress on ObservedAttestations
* Progress with ObservedAttestations
* Fix tests
* Add observed attestations to the beacon chain
* Add attestation observation to processing code
* Add progress on attestation verification
* Add first draft of ObservedAttesters
* Add more tests
* Add observed attesters to beacon chain
* Add observers to attestation processing
* Add more attestation verification
* Create ObservedAggregators map
* Remove commented-out code
* Add observed aggregators into chain
* Add progress
* Finish adding features to attestation verification
* Ensure beacon chain compiles
* Link attn verification into chain
* Integrate new attn verification in chain
* Remove old attestation processing code
* Start trying to fix beacon_chain tests
* Split adding into pools into two functions
* Add aggregation to harness
* Get test harness working again
* Adjust the number of aggregators for test harness
* Fix edge-case in harness
* Integrate new attn processing in network
* Fix compile bug in validator_client
* Update validator API endpoints
* Fix aggreagation in test harness
* Fix enum thing
* Fix attestation observation bug:
* Patch failing API tests
* Start adding comments to attestation verification
* Remove unused attestation field
* Unify "is block known" logic
* Update comments
* Supress fork choice errors for network processing
* Add todos
* Tidy
* Add gossip attn tests
* Disallow test harness to produce old attns
* Comment out in-progress tests
* Partially address pruning tests
* Fix failing store test
* Add aggregate tests
* Add comments about which spec conditions we check
* Dont re-aggregate
* Split apart test harness attn production
* Fix compile error in network
* Make progress on commented-out test
* Fix skipping attestation test
* Add fork choice verification tests
* Tidy attn tests, remove dead code
* Remove some accidentally added code
* Fix clippy lint
* Rename test file
* Add block tests, add cheap block proposer check
* Rename block testing file
* Add observed_block_producers
* Tidy
* Switch around block signature verification
* Finish block testing
* Remove gossip from signature tests
* First pass of self review
* Fix deviation in spec
* Update test spec tags
* Start moving over to hashset
* Finish moving observed attesters to hashmap
* Move aggregation pool over to hashmap
* Make fc attn borrow again
* Fix rest_api compile error
* Fix missing comments
* Fix monster test
* Uncomment increasing slots test
* Address remaining comments
* Remove unsafe, use cfg test
* Remove cfg test flag
* Fix dodgy comment
* Revert "Update hashmap hashset to stable futures"
This reverts commit d432378a3cc5cd67fc29c0b15b96b886c1323554.
* Revert "Adds panic test to hashset delay"
This reverts commit 281502396fc5b90d9c421a309c2c056982c9525b.
* Ported attestation_service
* Ported duties_service
* Ported fork_service
* More ports
* Port block_service
* Minor fixes
* VC compiles
* Update TODOS
* Borrow self where possible
* Ignore aggregates that are already known.
* Unify aggregator modulo logic
* Fix typo in logs
* Refactor validator subscription logic
* Avoid reproducing selection proof
* Skip HTTP call if no subscriptions
* Rename DutyAndState -> DutyAndProof
* Tidy logs
* Print root as dbg
* Fix compile errors in tests
* Fix compile error in test
* Re-Fix attestation and duties service
* Minor fixes
Co-authored-by: Paul Hauner <paul@paulhauner.com>
* Network crate update to stable futures
* Port account_manager to stable futures (#1121)
* Port account_manager to stable futures
* Run async fns in tokio environment
* Port rest_api crate to stable futures (#1118)
* Port rest_api lib to stable futures
* Reduce tokio features
* Update notifier to stable futures
* Builder update
* Further updates
* Convert self referential async functions
* stable futures fixes (#1124)
* Fix eth1 update functions
* Fix genesis and client
* Fix beacon node lib
* Return appropriate runtimes from environment
* Fix test rig
* Refactor eth1 service update
* Upgrade simulator to stable futures
* Lighthouse compiles on stable futures
* Remove println debugging statement
* Update libp2p service, start rpc test upgrade
* Update network crate for new libp2p
* Update tokio::codec to futures_codec (#1128)
* Further work towards RPC corrections
* Correct http timeout and network service select
* Use tokio runtime for libp2p
* Revert "Update tokio::codec to futures_codec (#1128)"
This reverts commit e57aea924acf5cbabdcea18895ac07e38a425ed7.
* Upgrade RPC libp2p tests
* Upgrade secio fallback test
* Upgrade gossipsub examples
* Clean up RPC protocol
* Test fixes (#1133)
* Correct websocket timeout and run on os thread
* Fix network test
* Clean up PR
* Correct tokio tcp move attestation service tests
* Upgrade attestation service tests
* Correct network test
* Correct genesis test
* Test corrections
* Log info when block is received
* Modify logs and update attester service events
* Stable futures: fixes to vc, eth1 and account manager (#1142)
* Add local testnet scripts
* Remove whiteblock script
* Rename local testnet script
* Move spawns onto handle
* Fix VC panic
* Initial fix to block production issue
* Tidy block producer fix
* Tidy further
* Add local testnet clean script
* Run cargo fmt
* Tidy duties service
* Tidy fork service
* Tidy ForkService
* Tidy AttestationService
* Tidy notifier
* Ensure await is not suppressed in eth1
* Ensure await is not suppressed in account_manager
* Use .ok() instead of .unwrap_or(())
* RPC decoding test for proto
* Update discv5 and eth2-libp2p deps
* Fix lcli double runtime issue (#1144)
* Handle stream termination and dialing peer errors
* Correct peer_info variant types
* Remove unnecessary warnings
* Handle subnet unsubscription removal and improve logigng
* Add logs around ping
* Upgrade discv5 and improve logging
* Handle peer connection status for multiple connections
* Improve network service logging
* Improve logging around peer manager
* Upgrade swarm poll centralise peer management
* Identify clients on error
* Fix `remove_peer` in sync (#1150)
* remove_peer removes from all chains
* Remove logs
* Fix early return from loop
* Improved logging, fix panic
* Partially correct tests
* Stable futures: Vc sync (#1149)
* Improve syncing heuristic
* Add comments
* Use safer method for tolerance
* Fix tests
* Stable futures: Fix VC bug, update agg pool, add more metrics (#1151)
* Expose epoch processing summary
* Expose participation metrics to prometheus
* Switch to f64
* Reduce precision
* Change precision
* Expose observed attesters metrics
* Add metrics for agg/unagg attn counts
* Add metrics for gossip rx
* Add metrics for gossip tx
* Adds ignored attns to prom
* Add attestation timing
* Add timer for aggregation pool sig agg
* Add write lock timer for agg pool
* Add more metrics to agg pool
* Change map lock code
* Add extra metric to agg pool
* Change lock handling in agg pool
* Change .write() to .read()
* Add another agg pool timer
* Fix for is_aggregator
* Fix pruning bug
Co-authored-by: pawan <pawandhananjay@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Paul Hauner <paul@paulhauner.com>
* Start updating types
* WIP
* Signature hacking
* Existing EF tests passing with fake_crypto
* Updates
* Delete outdated API spec
* The refactor continues
* It compiles
* WIP test fixes
* All release tests passing bar genesis state parsing
* Update and test YamlConfig
* Update to spec v0.10 compatible BLS
* Updates to BLS EF tests
* Add EF test for AggregateVerify
And delete unused hash2curve tests for uncompressed points
* Update EF tests to v0.10.1
* Use optional block root correctly in block proc
* Use genesis fork in deposit domain. All tests pass
* Cargo fmt
* Fast aggregate verify test
* Update REST API docs
* Cargo fmt
* Fix unused import
* Bump spec tags to v0.10.1
* Add `seconds_per_eth1_block` to chainspec
* Update to timestamp based eth1 voting scheme
* Return None from `get_votes_to_consider` if block cache is empty
* Handle overflows in `is_candidate_block`
* Revert to failing tests
* Fix eth1 data sets test
* Choose default vote according to spec
* Fix collect_valid_votes tests
* Fix `get_votes_to_consider` to choose all eligible blocks
* Uncomment winning_vote tests
* Add comments; remove unused code
* Reduce seconds_per_eth1_block for simulation
* Addressed review comments
* Add test for default vote case
* Fix logs
* Remove unused functions
* Meter default eth1 votes
* Fix comments
* Address review comments; remove unused dependency
* Add first attempt at attestation proc. re-write
* Add version 2 of attestation processing
* Minor fixes
* Add validator pubkey cache
* Make get_indexed_attestation take a committee
* Link signature processing into new attn verification
* First working version
* Ensure pubkey cache is updated
* Add more metrics, slight optimizations
* Clone committee cache during attestation processing
* Update shuffling cache during block processing
* Remove old commented-out code
* Fix shuffling cache insert bug
* Used indexed attestation in fork choice
* Restructure attn processing, add metrics
* Add more detailed metrics
* Tidy, fix failing tests
* Fix failing tests, tidy
* Disable/delete two outdated tests
* Tidy
* Add pubkey cache persistence file
* Add more comments
* Integrate persistence file into builder
* Add pubkey cache tests
* Add data_dir to beacon chain builder
* Remove Option in pubkey cache persistence file
* Ensure consistency between datadir/data_dir
* Fix failing network test
* Tidy
* Fix todos
* Add attestation processing tests
* Add another test
* Only run attestation tests in release
* Make attestation tests MainnetEthSpec
* Address Michael's comments
* Remove redundant check
* Fix warning
* Fix failing test
Co-authored-by: Michael Sproul <micsproul@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Pawan Dhananjay <pawandhananjay@gmail.com>
